May 8, 2024

Bitcoin Mixers: Enhance Privacy, Understand the Risks

Understand Bitcoin mixers: how they work, legal concerns, and choosing one

Bitcoin Mixers: Enhance Privacy, Understand the Risks

Bitcoin's public ledger raises privacy concerns, prompting the emergence of mixers to enhance anonymity, though users must be cautious of risks and legal implications

Despite bitcoin’s widespread adoption and decentralized nature, its public ledger raises significant privacy concerns. To address these, bitcoin mixers have emerged as a solution. Transactions made using bitcoin are recorded on the blockchain, allowing anyone to analyze and trace the flow of funds. This transparency can compromise the privacy of users.

A bitcoin mixer, also known as a tumbler or mixer, is a service that helps users enhance the privacy and anonymity of their transactions by mixing their coins with those of others. By doing so, they obscure the trail of transactions, making it challenging to trace the origin and destination of the funds.

Are Bitcoin Mixers Legal?

The legality of bitcoin mixers varies depending on jurisdiction and their specific use case. Technically, a bitcoin mixer is not inherently illegal. However, mixers drew scrutiny from regulatory bodies due to their potential use in money laundering and illicit activities. It's essential to conduct thorough research and understand the legal implications of using bitcoin mixers in your country.

In the US, for example, even mixers that do not operate within the country's borders are required to register:

“The U.S. Treasury Department’s unprecedented proposal—using laws usually deployed against foreign banks and foreign jurisdictions—will require special record-keeping and reporting for any financial transactions involving international mixers. The potential targeting of an entire class of transactions represents a significant regulatory step meant to shape the future of the global financial system. ”

Many regulators focus on KYC (Know Your Customer) and AML (Anti-Money Laundering) compliance when scrutinizing bitcoin mixing services.

CoinJoin vs. Coin Mixer

CoinJoin and Coin Mixer are both methods used to enhance the privacy of bitcoin transactions. CoinJoin is a software-based approach where multiple transactions are combined into a single transaction, making it difficult to trace the original source of funds. On the other hand, Coin Mixer typically refers to a service provided by a company that mixes users' coins to obfuscate their transaction history.

As a general guideline, CoinJoins tend to be more decentralized and consequently considered legal. Mixers may be legal if the companies overseeing them adhere to the regulations specific to their jurisdiction.

Samourai Wallet’s Whirlpool 

Samourai Wallet's Whirlpool is a popular bitcoin collaborative transaction tool that employs the CoinJoin method to enhance privacy. Whirlpool combines multiple transactions from different users into a single transaction, making it challenging to trace the origin of the coins. By using Whirlpool, users can enhance their privacy and anonymity on the Bitcoin network. 

Please be aware that users are required to pay coordinator fees.

Wasabi Wallet and Its Lack of Censorship Resistance

Wasabi Wallet is another prominent bitcoin wallet that provides CoinJoin functionality to enhance privacy. Nonetheless, users should note that utilizing CoinJoin transactions through Wasabi Wallet incurs a coordinator fee of 0.3%. Additionally, users will have to cover the standard Bitcoin network fees. Despite its focus on privacy, Wasabi Wallet has faced criticism:

“The company that runs the default server for all Wasabi Wallet clients buys data from a chain analysis provider to prevent some inputs from registering with its coinjoin service. Although it introduces no privacy tradeoff, this highlights the lack of censorship resistance.”

The Tornado Cash Case 

Tornado Cash is a decentralized Ethereum mixer designed to enhance privacy for Ethereum transactions. However, in August 2022, one of its developers, Alexey Pertsev, was arrested in The Netherlands. Despite not directly participating in the alleged money laundering activities, Pertsev faced accusations in connection with the misuse of the Tornado Cash service by North Korean cybercrime groups. 

His arrest underscores the legal complexities surrounding privacy-focused projects and highlights the regulatory challenges confronting developers in this arena. Recently, a Dutch court concluded Pertsev's trial with a request for a 64-month prison term over alleged involvement in a $1.2 billion laundering scheme. 

Additionally, Roman Storm and Roman Semenov, other developers associated with Tornado Cash, are reportedly facing money laundering allegations in the United States.

Exchanges That Don’t Allow CoinJoin Transactions

Some exchanges and associated services enforce policies that prohibit or restrict the use of CoinJoin transactions. These exchanges often cite regulatory concerns and anti-money laundering (AML) regulations as reasons for their policies. Before using CoinJoin services, users should be mindful of these restrictions. 

Other Available Bitcoin Mixers

Please note that we cannot endorse these services. Do your own comprehensive research before utilizing any of these mixers.

In Conclusion 

We are still in the early stages of the Bitcoin revolution. Bitcoin mixers play a crucial role in enhancing the privacy and anonymity of bitcoin transactions. However, users should be aware of the potential risks and legal implications associated with their use. Conducting thorough research and understanding the features of different bitcoin mixers is essential to making informed decisions about privacy-enhancing tools.

About the author.